After penning an emotional and earnest tribute to Jason Botchford (seriously, read it here if you haven’t already), our own Jackson McDonald is off on a well-deserved vacation—and so yours truly has the honour of handling the last Monday Mailbag of the offseason.
do you see any path for macewen to make the team out of camp?
— just what i need to see. star wolf (@RisaHeavenFever) September 12, 2019
Based on Cory Hergott’s reporting, it sounds like Zack MacEwen has taken yet another step forward this offseason—and so, one would hope he’s opened some doors for himself that were previously closed.
“The Big Fella” has two things working against him when it comes to making the Canucks out of camp—the plethora of forwards slotted ahead of him in the depth chart and the fact that he doesn’t need to pass through waivers to be assigned to Utica. MacEwen will already have to outcompete several other wingers to make the cut, and even then he’d likely need another forward like Brandon Sutter or Nikolay Goldobin to be moved out first for roster-shuffling purposes.
The most likely scenario is that MacEwen starts in Utica and is first on the priority list for forward call-ups—but that’s still pretty good for an undrafted 23-year-old.
What would Jake Marner or Mitch Virtanen look like?
— Botchford's Mouth Guard (RIP) (@BoesersMG) September 14, 2019
If we’re talking skillset, we’re talking a dominant top-line winger. Combine Mitch Marner’s silky smooth hands and laser-focused offensive vision with Jake Virtanen’s physical attributes and raw power—and you’ve got yourself a player who can take the puck to the net, deke the opposing team out of their collective shorts, and wire it home.
If we’re talking a hypothetical love-child, however, we’re left with this flesh-toothed monstrosity:
How much is too much for Boesar.
— CanuckJake16 (@CanuckJake16) September 14, 2019
As of this writing, Brock Boeser has yet to be re-signed—though this author is fairly confident that the contract will be inked sometime in the next 24 hours. Currently, the question of “too much” relies entirely on the term of the deal, and so we’ll look at a couple different scenarios.
On a four-year deal, Timo Meier represents a nice upper-limit—anything significantly higher than $6 million would probably be too much.
A five-year deal takes Boeser right to UFA status, and should be avoided at all cost.
A six-year deal is where things start to get interesting. Boeser’s camp has reportedly turned down a $42 million offer over six seasons. One would think that anything over $8 million at such a term would be too much, but then it’s hard to argue that Mitch Marner is really worth a full $3 million more than Boeser—so it’s possible to see this one extend even higher.
Anything in the six- to seven-year range, however, will likely see Boeser’s camp asking for something north of $8.5 million—what with the Seattle expansion and a new TV deal on the horizon. Given Boeser’s injury history, the Canucks probably aren’t all that interested in this scenario.
Was Jake’s cardio testing poor? Or just his bag skate performance. Poor bag skate performance doesn’t necessarily equate to poor conditioning.
— Peter Genge (@peter_genge) September 14, 2019
There haven’t been any details as to which “targets” Jake Virtanen missed, but one would have to guess that they related to specific scores on certain preseason fitness tests—as per the talk of Virtanen just barely missing them. Given Virtanen’s history, cardio-related goals aren’t a bad guess.
In any case, Virtanen has already returned to the main groups and participated in a scrimmage since this question was asked, so it’s probably a moot point now.
Best burger in town?
— mike higashi (@hirokidude) September 14, 2019
I’m not a Vancouver local, so I’m operating from limited knowledge—but last time I was there I had a fantastic burger from Steamworks, so let’s go with that. If we’re talking fast food, it’s definitely either Five Guys or Fatburger.
I’m on the way to vegetarianism, though, so I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention The Black Lodge—an excellent Twin Peaks-themed pub in Mount Pleasant.
Not seen much discussion about it but where does Baertschi fit in this team. Will he be with Bo again or some new teammates will be tried?
— Henry Crutching (@HCrutching) September 14, 2019
Our official fan-voted lineup placed Sven Baertschi on the third line alongside Adam Gaudette and Jake Virtanen—and I have to agree with our esteemed readers. Baertschi has had success with Bo Horvat before, but he’s also had success elsewhere. Compare that to Tanner Pearson, who has had his only success of the last few seasons when paired with Horvat, and it’s pretty obvious that Pearson should get first priority.
The Canucks would probably benefit most from having Baertschi elevate the play of others on an offensive third line rather than supplementing the already-excellent offense of Horvat.
Does Zack MacEwen make the team out of camp forcing a Virtanen trade? What kind of value is JV worth? 2nd in 2020 and 3rd in 2021?
— Ron#1Canucksfan (@RonSimp16154192) September 14, 2019
Since we covered Zack MacEwen above, we’ll tackle the Jake Virtanen portion of this question here. Personally, I don’t see Virtanen being moved at this juncture—but if he were to be moved, recouping some draft picks would probably be the way to go. It’s hard to imagine Virtanen would return a first round pick, but a second and a third would also seem a bit underwhelming given his untapped potential—another reason I don’t see a trade happening quite yet.
The idea of a Jesse Puljujarvi swap has been proposed, but such a trade wouldn’t help with the glut at forward—and Virtanen might just be the superior asset at this point in time.
Will Arthur’s Silovs get into any preseason games and will he go back to Europe or to Barrie after camp?
— WhiskerBob (@BobWhisker) September 14, 2019
I would be surprised if Arturs Silovs got into any preseason action this year—but then again, I was surprised that he signed an entry-level contract already, so anything is possible. Chances are that Jim Benning and Co. want to get a look at all of Zane McIntyre, Jake Kielly, and Mike DiPietro in the preseason—as well as getting Thatcher Demko at least a couple starts—so there’s just not that much time left for Silovs.
The Barrie #Colts have received word that Latvian G Arturs Silovs will be playing with them this season. Nothing yet done formally however.
He will arrive after Canucks camp.#OHL
— OHLInsiders (@OHLinsiders) August 27, 2019
The word on the street is that Silovs will be assigned to the Barrie Colts following training camp, though that’s yet to be officially confirmed:
Another question? Due to cap restraints can you see teams having a 22 man roster? If canucks deploy that strategy they might have to move farm team closer?
— mike higashi (@hirokidude) September 14, 2019
I think the lower-than-expected salary cap for 2019/20 caught a lot of teams off-guard, and that will cause a handful of teams to roll with a 22-man roster to start the year—but I don’t think the Canucks will be one of them. Unless the Boeser contract negotiations spiral out of control, Vancouver will have plenty of cap space for at least this season—and as one of the most oft-injured franchises in the league, they really can’t afford to skimp on extra players.
As for moving the farm team closer, it’s not happening anytime soon. The Canucks and Comets renewed their affiliation last season and neither side seems interested in a change. It’s also important to note that any AHL affiliate placed in the Lower Mainland—say Abbotsford, for example—would spend an inordinate amount of time on the road, so call-ups wouldn’t really be any more convenient than they currently are.
What are your predictions for this year's top 5 point scorers on the Canucks (assuming Boeser gets signed)? By all means give predictive point totals!
— Tom Taylor (@TomTaylor28) September 15, 2019
You want predictive point totals? I’ll give you predictive point totals!
I think the top-five scorers will almost certainly be a combination of Elias Pettersson, Brock Boeser, Bo Horvat, JT Miller, and one of Tanner Pearson or Micheal Ferland—unless injuries are a factor, of course.
In terms of predictions, let’s go with some nice, round numbers:
Elias Pettersson at 85 points
Brock Boeser at 80 points
Bo Horvat at 65 points
JT Miller at 55 points
Micheal Ferland at 45 points
That’s it for now, folks, but I’ll probably be able to cobble together a Part Two out of past unanswered questions, so keep an eye out for that later this week. Thanks everyone!